
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Experimental Therapeutics, Preclinical Pharmacology |
Emitting Radioimmunotherapy Using 213Bi 1,4,7,10-Tetraazacyclododecane-N,N',N'',N'''-Tetraacetic Acid-Biotin
1 Nuclear Medicine and 2 Positron Emission Tomography, 2Department of the Warren G. Magnuson Clinical Center, 3 Metabolism Branch, 4 Laboratory of Molecular Biology, and 5 Radiation Oncology Branch of the National Cancer Institute, NIH, Bethesda, Maryland, and 6 NeoRx Corporation, Seattle, Washington
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
emitter for radioimmunotherapy has potential advantages compared with ß emitters. When administered systemically optimal targeting of intact antibodies requires >24 h, therefore limiting the use of short-lived
emitters. This study investigated the biodistribution of bismuth-labeled biotin in A431 tumor-bearing mice pretargeted with antibody B3-streptavidin (B3-SA) and examined the therapeutic efficacy of the
emitter, 213Bi-labeled biotin. Experimental Design: Biotinidase-resistant 7,10-tetraazacyclododecane-N,N',N'',N'''-tetraacetic acid (DOTA)-biotin was radiolabeled with 205,206Bi or 213Bi. Treatment of tumor-bearing mice began by administration of B3-SA (400 µg) to target the tumor sites for 24 h. Then, an agent containing biotin and galactose groups was used to clear the conjugate from the circulation. Four h later, bismuth-radiolabeled DOTA-biotin was given, and biodistribution or therapy was evaluated. Dose escalation treatment from 3.774 MBq was performed, and the effects on tumors of different sizes were investigated. Tumor growth, complete blood cell counts, toxicity, and survival were monitored.
Results: Radiolabeled biotin cleared rapidly. Rapid tumor uptake resulted in much higher tumor:nontumor targeting ratios than achieved with the directly labeled monoclonal antibody. Dose escalation revealed that 74 MBq caused acute death of mice, whereas 0.3737 MBq doses inhibited tumor growth and prolonged survival significantly. Evidence of mild hematological toxicity was noted. At therapeutically effective doses renal toxicity was observed.
Conclusions: 213Bi-DOTA-biotin, directed by the Pretarget method to tumor-targeted B3-SA, showed a therapeutic effect, although the therapeutic index was low. The source of the toxicity was most likely related to the renal toxicity.
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Compared with ß emitters,
emitters have certain theoretical advantages, higher linear energy transfer with DNA damage that is difficult to repair, reduced nonspecific irradiation to normal tissues around the target cells because of their shorter path lengths (µm), and hypoxia-insensitive cytotoxicity. Bismuth radioisotopes (212Bi and 213Bi) and 211At have been used in preclinical trials, and some clinical applications are currently being explored (12, 13, 14)
. Because of its short half-life (46 min), 213Bi will be limited to systems with rapid delivery and targeting. Rapid delivery can be obtained when targeting circulating cells or cellular targets that are rapidly accessible, such as in the endothelial vasculature, spleen, and bone marrow, or when local delivery can be performed (14, 15, 16)
. In most clinical situations, optimal targeting of both hematological and epithelial malignancies with intact antibodies requires >24 h. Therefore, pretargeting approaches, in which delivery of the large molecular weight antibody and the small molecule radionuclide are uncoupled from each other, appear to be reasonable alternatives for tumor targeting with short-lived radionuclides.
Intact immunoglobulins have limited accessibility into solid tumors because of their size (17) . In addition, because of increased pressure gradients in tumors, the kinetics of delivery are slow (18) . Furthermore, there is often heterogeneity in the distribution of intact IgG because of binding site barriers (19) . Several approaches have been tried to overcome these problems, including utilization of small molecular weight fragments that target tumors faster (17) or alternatively using intact antibodies that can be modified for use in pretargeting protocols (20, 21, 22) . One approach, termed the Pretarget method, has been developed by NeoRx Corporation (Seattle, WA; Refs. 23, 24, 25 ). This approach is based on the streptavidin (SA) biotin system (20) . The Pretarget method consists of three steps: (a) the antibody-SA conjugate is administered and allowed to target and accumulate in the tumor, thus carrying the SA receptor that can later bind the radiolabeled biotin; (b) the nontumor-bound antibody-SA is removed from the circulation by administration of a synthetic clearing agent to prevent it from binding the biotin-radionuclide in the circulation; and (c) the biotin-radionuclide is administered i.v. for delivery of radiotherapy. Because of its small size, the radiolabeled biotin extravasates out of the circulation quickly, where it can bind to the SA on the antibody-SA conjugate that has already localized in the tumor. In addition, because of its small size the intravascular radioactivity clears very rapidly through the kidneys. Preclinical studies have characterized the pharmacokinetics of the system and optimized the three reagents used in this approach (25) . In addition, preclinical trials with genetically synthesized single-chain Fv-derived tetravalent fusion proteins have also shown favorable kinetics and biodistribution (26) . Clinical trials have shown the feasibility of using this Pretarget approach to deliver large radiation doses to target tissue (23 , 24) . We also demonstrated recently that cures could be achieved in an adult T-cell leukemia scid/nod mice tumor xenograft model using the 213Bi anti-Tac streptavidin conjugate (16) .
We have shown previously that B3, an anti-Ley murine IgG1 monoclonal antibody, can efficiently target A431 tumor xenografts in nude mice (27) . This work led to a Phase I therapy trial with 111In and 90Y B3 in patients with a variety of tumor types bearing the target antigen. In those studies, we demonstrated good tumor targeting, but no therapeutic responses were observed, presumably because of the limited dose delivered (28) . We have demonstrated recently that the B3 monoclonal antibody conjugated to streptavidin (B3-SA) concentrated significantly in our A431 tumor xenograft model (29) . Despite somewhat inhomogeneous tumor concentration, as demonstrated by autoradiography, pretargeted 90Y 1,4,7,10-tetraazacyclododecane-N,N',N'',N'''-tetraacetic acid (DOTA) biotin, with its long-range ß particle, was able to deliver a sufficient dose to result in tumor cures. In the current study, we investigated the feasibility of the three-step Pretarget approach using radiolabeled bismuth 213Bi-DOTA-biotin and the same B3-SA conjugate.
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
receptor, but does not react with the A431 cell line and, thus, was used as a negative control (31
, 32)
. HAT was obtained from Hoffmann LaRoche (Nutley, NJ).
Pretarget Reagents.
B3 was conjugated to SA by using succinimidyl 4-(N-maleimido-methyl) cyclohexane-1-carboxylate as described previously (25
, 29)
. To determine that the B3-SA conjugate was still functional, 111In-DOTA-biotin was incubated with excess B3-SA. The bound fraction was then determined by paper chromatography developed with saline and was >99% (3MM; Whatman International Ltd., Maidstone, England). The bound fraction was also >99% when measured using avidin gel (Pierce Biotechnology, Rockford, IL). Previous studies showed good localization of B3-SA in our tumor system after administration of 400 µg and optimal tumor localization by 48 h (29)
. HAT-SA was prepared using chemistry similar to that of B3-SA (16)
.
Synthetic clearing agent (sCA) was provided by the NeoRx Corp. This reagent consists of a bifunctional moiety with multiple N-acetyl-galactosamine residues linked to a single biotin (molecular weight = 8651; Ref. 33
). The biotin on the sCA binds rapidly to circulating antibody-SA conjugate. This reagent has been shown to clear antibody-SA conjugates rapidly out of the circulation and into the liver via the Ashwell receptors present in the liver (26)
. Our previous studies administering 100 µg of sCA to mice receiving 400 µg of radiolabeled B3-SA showed a mean drop of 90% of the circulating antibody-SA conjugate, indicating that the sCA was functional and effective (29)
. Therefore, the dose of sCA selected for this study was 100 µg. Biotinidase-resistant DOTA-biotin (molecular weight =
900; NeoRx Corp.) was prepared as described previously (34)
. B3 was conjugated to CHX-A'' as described previously (35)
. The CHX-A'' conjugate was then labeled with 205,206Bi for biodistribution studies comparing directly labeled antibody to pretargeted radionuclide-antibody delivery.
Radiolabeling.
Although our interest was in radioimmunotherapy with 213Bi, the short half-life and limited availability led us to perform our initial biodistribution studies for proof of concept using the longer lived
-emitting mixture of 205,206Bi that has a half-life of 15.21 and 6.243 days, respectively. The 205,206Bi was produced in the positron emission tomography department of the NIH by irradiation of a high purity lead target (36)
with 25 MeV protons using a CS-30 cyclotron, and purification was performed as described previously (37)
.
For radioimmunotherapy, 213Bi was used. The 213Bi was eluted from a 225Ac generator (38)
. The 225Ac (Oak Ridge National Laboratories, Oak Ridge, TN) was dissolved in 0.1 M HNO3 and loaded onto an MP-50 cation exchange resin pre-equilibrated with 0.1 M HNO3. The breakthrough of 225Ac was
83 parts/million as determined by measuring the 213Bi activity 16 h after elution using a germanium lithium high-resolution detector.
Biotinidase-resistant DOTA-biotin was radiolabeled with 205,206Bi at a specific activity of 1.46 MBq/µg based on the method of Axworthy et al. (25) . In brief, DOTA-biotin was added to the purified 205,206Bi, and the pH was adjusted to 55.5 with 5 M NH4OAc and then incubated for 12 min at 90°C. To scavenge unreacted Bi, 5 µl of 5 mM DTPA was added to the reaction mixture. The radiochemical yield and bindability of radiolabeled DOTA-biotin was >99% as measured using an avidin gel. For radioimmunotherapy studies, the DOTA-biotin was labeled with 213Bi as described above at specific activities of 3788 MBq/µg.
For comparison of biodistribution, B3 CHX-A''antibody conjugate was labeled with 205,206Bi at a specific activity of >37 kBq/µg. Unmodified B3 and B3-SA was also labeled with 125I using p-iodobenzoate method (PIB; Perkin-Elmer Life Sciences, Inc., Boston, MA) at specific activity
37 kBq/µg for immunoreactivity measurements (29)
.
Cell Line.
A431, a human epidermoid carcinoma cell line that expresses the antigen recognized by B3, but not by HAT, was used. This cell line was used for immunoreactivity determination and for the development of tumor xenografts. Cells were grown in RPMI 1640 supplemented with 10% FCS, 2 mM L-glutamine, penicillin (100 IU/ml), and streptomycin (100 µg/ml) at 37°C in a moist atmosphere with 5% CO2. Cells were harvested with EDTA-trypsin and resuspended in PBS for immunoreactivity assay and mouse inoculation for tumor xenograft generation.
Immunoreactivity Assay.
The immunoreactivity of the B3-SA conjugate used for these experiments was determined previously by labeling with 125I (6873%) and was in the range of the unmodified 125I-labeled B3 parent MoAb (29)
. The immunoreactivity of 205,206Bi-labeled B3 CHX-A'' was also determined using the same binding assay. In brief, a constant concentration of 205,206Bi-labeled B3 CHX-A'' (5 ng) was incubated with 2 x 104 to 2 x 106 of A431 cells for 2 h at 4°C. Cell-bound radioactivity was separated by centrifugation and counted in a gamma counter. The cell-bound fraction of 205,206Bi-labeled B3 CHX-A'' was 66%.
Tumor Model.
Animal experiments were performed under a protocol approved by NIH Animal Care and Use Committee. Athymic female mice (nu/nu) were inoculated s.c. (0.1 ml) with 3 x 106 A431 cells in the right flank. Biodistribution studies were performed
12 days after inoculation when tumors reached
0.5 cm in maximal diameter. To evaluate the effect of tumor size on response to radioimmunotherapy with 213Bi-DOTA-biotin, some mice with tumor xenografts were studied at earlier or later times after inoculation when the tumors were smaller or bigger than those generally obtained at 12 days. Seven days before all of the pretargeting experiments, the mice were fed with a biotin-free diet (Biotin Deficient Purina Diet 5836C; Purina Mills, Richmond, IN) to reduce the endogenous biotin level (29)
. Twenty-four h after injection of radiolabeled DOTA-biotin, their regular diet was resumed. Mice were sacrificed when the tumor size reached >2 cm in the longest diameter, the tumor was ulcerated, or excessive weight loss (>25%) was noted, according to our NIH animal protocol guidelines.
Biodistribution.
Tumor-bearing mice were injected via the tail vein with 400 µg/0.2 ml of B3-SA conjugate for pretargeting. After allowing tumor pretargeting of B3-SA for 24 h, 100 µg/0.1 ml of sCA was given to clear the circulating B3-SA conjugate from the blood. Four h later, 205,206Bi-labeled DOTA-biotin (1 µg) typically in 0.2 ml was injected i.v. In all of the studies, 1 µg of DOTA-biotin was used, by adding cold carrier, if necessary. Groups of 5 mice were sacrificed at 0.5, 1, 2, and 4 h after injection of the pretargeted radiolabel. In a separate experiment to determine the reproducibility of pretargeting, the biodistribution measurements were repeated at 1 h (data not shown) and 4 h after pretargeted 205,206Bi-labeled DOTA-biotin was injected. In addition, the biodistribution of 205,206Bi directly labeled to B3-CHX-A'' (5 µg) was determined at 4 h in a separate group of mice and then compared with the pretargeted biodistribution. Additional biodistribution studies were performed at 5 min and 15 min after pretargeted 213Bi-DOTA-biotin was administered. Tumors and all of the major organs were harvested, weighed, and counted in a gamma counter. Counting of the carcasses was also performed to obtain the whole body clearance by accounting for all of the radioactivity in the mice. The percentage of the injected dose per gram (%ID/g) in tissue was calculated for each organ and normalized to a 20-g mouse (Table 1)
. Tumor:tissue ratios were also determined. To determine whether tumors size had an effect on %ID/g accumulation of pretargeted bismuth-DOTA-biotin we took the largest and the smallest tumor and compared the differences in %ID/g accumulated [ (%ID/g large tumor %ID/g small tumor)/%ID/g small tumor] for each of the biodistribution times (Table 2)
.
|
|
particles from 213Bi decay (12)
.
Therapy.
Radioimmunotherapy was performed in A431 tumor-bearing mice using 213Bi DOTA-biotin after pretargeting with B3-SA, and clearance from the blood was performed, as described above in the pretargeting reagent section. Initially, groups of 5 mice each were treated in a dose escalation trial with 3.7, 9.25, 18.5, and 37 MBq of 213Bi-DOTA-biotin and compared with a no-treatment control group (therapy trial 1).
In a second experiment (therapy trial 2), a group of 10 mice was treated (10 days after tumor inoculation) with 37 MBq 213Bi-DOTA-biotin after the same pretargeting approach and compared with a no-treatment control group. These tumors are referred to as of medium size (Table 3)
. In addition, to evaluate the effect of tumor size on therapeutic response, 2 groups of 10 mice each were treated at 7 days (small tumors) or 13 days (large tumors; Table 3
). One group of mice (n = 5) bearing medium-size tumors was treated with 74 MBq of 213Bi-DOTA-biotin after pretargeting with B3-SA, and another group (n = 10) was treated with 37 MBq of 213Bi-DOTA-biotin after nonspecific pretargeting with HAT-SA, which served as a control.
|
To determine hematological toxicity, 20 µl of blood was collected from the tail veins using an EDTA-coated capillary tube and diluted to 250 µl with PBS (n = 5/group). Complete blood count (CBC), total and differential leukocyte, RBC, and platelet counts were performed before therapy and at weekly intervals thereafter until the time of death to monitor hematological toxicity. CBC from therapy trials 1 and 2 in tumor-bearing mice receiving 37 MBq of 213Bi-DOTA-biotin after pretargeting with B3-SA were combined and analyzed (n = 10).
Liver and kidney function parameters were determined in tumor-bearing mice at the time of sacrifice (chemistry required relatively large blood volumes and, thus, they were done at the time of animal euthanasia after therapy trial 1 or therapy trial 2). Because control animals had to be euthanized in <2 weeks, only early CBC and chemistry results were available. In the 213BiDOTA-biotin-treated groups after pretargeting, delayed time points were obtained at the time of euthanasia. According to our protocol, animals were sacrificed when tumors were too large, the mice had excessive weight loss, or tumor ulceration occurred. At sacrifice, a blood sample was taken by heart puncture and the serum separated for chemistries. A group of nontumor-bearing mice that received 213Bi-DOTA-biotin without pretargeting had liver and renal function analyses evaluated at 7 days and 21 days after administration of 213Bi-DOTA-biotin.
Nontumor-bearing mice, including nontreatment controls, and groups receiving 1.85 MBq, 9.25 MBq, and 37 MBq 213BiDOTA-biotin with and without pretargeting were autopsied at 7 days (n = 3/group 213Bi-DOTA-biotin treatment and n = 4 control) or 21 days (n = 3/group) after treatment with 213BiDOTA-biotin and at 6 months (n = 3 for control and 1.85 MBq and n = 4 receiving 9.25 MBq/group). Tumor-bearing mice receiving treatment with 0, 3.7, 9.25, 18.5, and 37 MBq of 213Bi-DOTA-biotin after pretargeting with B3-SA or with 37 MBq of 213Bi-DOTA-biotin after pretargeting with HAT-SA were autopsied (n = 23). The time of autopsy of the tumor-bearing mice varied because the time of euthanasia was determined by large tumor size, excessive weight loss, or tumor ulceration. Typically, pathological evaluation of liver, kidney, intestine, lung, bone marrow, and tumor were performed. Tissue samples were harvested and fixed in 10% formalin for pathology studies. The tissues were examined by a veterinary pathologist.
Statistics.
Comparison between baseline and follow-up chemistries was done using paired t test statistics. Comparison of toxicity after therapy was performed using one-way repeated measure ANOVA when multiple samples were drawn per mouse over time. All of the analyses were performed using Sigmastat software (Jandel, San Rafael, CA). Survival curves were analyzed using Kaplan-Meier method for survival data (Graph Pad Prism).
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
-radiation, we estimated 105.74 Sv/37MBq.
|
0.2 cm3 in volume immediately before the B3-SA pretargeting to
2 cm3 in <2 weeks, and the mean time to quadrupling their tumor size was 4.6 days. These mice were sacrificed when the tumors were >2 cm in length (<10 days). The tumor growth of the no-treatment control tumor-bearing mice in the second therapy study showed a mean time to quadruple the tumor volume of 6.5 days that was somewhat slower than the therapy 1 group and due to a slightly smaller mean baseline volume of 0.138 cm3 versus 0.273 cm3 for control group of the first therapy. After treatment, inhibition of tumor growth and prolongation of survival were shown with doses of 3.7 MBq of 213Bi or greater (P < 0.03, Kaplan-Meier). The median survivals of the groups were 7, 14, 41, 83, and 57 days for no-treatment control, and 3.7, 9.25, 18.5, and 37 MBq of 213Bi-DOTA-biotin pretargeted groups, respectively (Fig. 2)
|
|
Toxicity.
Toxicity evaluation in nontumor-bearing mice was performed. All of the tumor-bearing mice receiving 74 MBq of 213Bi showed acute toxicity with death by 5 days. Shortly after the time of their death, autopsy showed that the kidneys of these mice were visually swollen and pale compared with normal kidneys. Some mice receiving 3.737 MBq became less active and died unexpectedly for unknown reasons without large tumor burden. Nontumor-bearing mice receiving 213Bi-DOTA-biotin in doses ranging from 0 to 37 MBq were sacrificed at 7 days, 21 days, and in addition mice receiving 0 (control), 1.85 and 9.26 MBq were also sacrificed at 6 months. Findings of treated groups were compared with control, and the results are shown in Table 5
. No pathological findings were seen in the liver and intestines of mice at doses up to 37 MBq compared with controls. The toxicity observed was predominantly in the kidney, marrow, and spleen, and appeared to be dose dependent. No bone marrow hypocellularity was seen at 3 weeks after treatment with up to 37 MBq of 213Bi-DOTA-biotin. At 6 months, pathology of nontumor-bearing mice receiving 1.85 or 9.25 MBq was compared with that of controls. Some evidence of kidney toxicity was seen at 6 months in the histology of the 9.25 MBq-treated mice compared with the control (Table 5)
. One of the mice in the 9.25 MBq group had histological evidence of lymphoma, but no other significant findings were seen in comparison with the control groups. In addition to pathology, changes in organ weight were evaluated as a possible surrogate of toxicity. There was no significant difference in the weight of the livers or kidneys among these groups. The weight of the spleen of the control group was significantly more than that of the 37 MBq group (mean = 0.107 g versus 0.027 g, respectively; P < 0.05).
|
Tumor-bearing mice receiving 37 MBq of pretargeted 213Bi-DOTA-biotin after B3-SA had their CBCs monitored to evaluate toxicity, and their data are shown in Table 6
. A significant drop in lymphocytes was seen by day 7, which recovered by day 35. The platelet count also showed a significant decrease by day 7 that then tended to recover to approximately 7586% of baseline by 2135 days. Data for the lower doses is not shown, but a drop in lymphocytes was also seen at the 18.5 MBq and 9.25 MBq 213Bi-DOTA-biotin levels. No platelet, neutrophil, or RBC toxicity was seen at the 9.25 MBq. Platelet toxicity was seen at the 18.5 MBq level, which was in the range of that seen with the 37 MBq dose. No change in neutrophil was seen at 18.5 MBq level.
|
|
0.05) as compared with the controls but no significant increase for the B3-SA pretargeted group (0.1 ± 0.1 mg/dl, 0.2 ± 0.15 mg/dl, versus 0.2 + 0.2 mg/dl, respectively). The BUN values were increased significantly in the B3-SA pretargeted group (median 29 mg/dl; P < 0.05) compared with the control group (median 19 mg/dl) with a trend toward higher BUN in the HAT-SA pretargeted group (median 21 mg/dl). No significant differences were seen in liver function tests (bilirubin, alkaline phosphatase, alanine aminotransferase, or aspartate aminotransferase) among any of the three groups. In summary, at the doses of 213Bi-DOTA-biotin that showed biologically meaningful efficacy, there was toxicity predominantly affecting the kidney. | DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In contrast to ß emitters with long-range emissions, the range of
particles is very short and not expected to have a large effect on cells that are not immediately adjacent to the
emitters. Our prior autoradiographic studies have shown that there is an inhomogeneous distribution of antibody within the A431 tumor (29)
, and thus the short pathlength of 213Bi
-particle is expected to be less successful in irradiating areas of the tumor that have low uptake than the emission of a ß emitter such as 90Y, which has a mean pathlength of 5 mm. Other studies using
emitters for therapy have also shown poorer tumor responses in larger lesions. Kennel et al. (15)
, using a lung metastasis model, demonstrated that 213Bi targeted with an intact antibody could cure small tumors, but cures were not observed with larger tumors, although there was a tumor growth delay. Similar results in a model system using a 213Bi plasminogen activator inhibitor type 2 construct demonstrated better tumor responses with smaller tumors (41)
. Similar findings have been reported with an
emitter, 212Bi-labeled antibody (42)
. Previous studies by our group suggest that, as expected, 213Bi-DOTA-biotin could be quite efficacious in a leukemia model (16
, 43)
in comparison with the more limited efficacy with tumor nodules. In contrast, the 90Y-DOTA-biotin was more effective in the treatment of nodules than in the treatment of the isolated cells in the leukemia model (16
, 29)
. The latter findings were consistent with our data, where more favorable responses with tumor nodules were seen with 90Y DOTA-biotin after pretargeting (29)
.
As we escalated the doses of 213Bi-DOTA-biotin there was evidence of improved survival in the various groups studied. Some were complete responders with 18.5 or 37 MBq of 213Bi-DOTA-biotin, but these animals died of radiotoxicity nonetheless. Thus, the therapeutic margin with this
emitter in the treatment of tumor nodules was unfavorable. When larger doses were administered (74 MBq of 213Bi), the animals died rapidly, and whereas no chemistry or histopathology was available, visual examination demonstrated morphological changes in the kidneys suggesting renal toxicity. The control animals had to be sacrificed electively because of large tumor size. Toxicity resulting in death was seen in 2 of 5 of the 3.7 MBq group and in 4 of 5 of the 9.75 MBq group, as well as in 4 of 5 of the 18.5 MBq group and in the entire 37 MBq group. Similarly, in the second therapy trial in which mice received 37 MBq, almost all of the animals receiving 213Bi-DOTA-biotin after pretargeting with B3-SA died of toxicity.
Although plasma chemistry and pathology were available in only a small group of animals, the findings suggest that the main toxicity was renal. Renal toxicity findings were noted in the pathology of both nontumor-bearing animals receiving 213Bi-DOTA-biotin without pretargeting and tumor-bearing mice undergoing 213Bi-DOTA-biotin after pretargeting with B3-SA. Some of these changes were seen as early as 1-week after treatment, whereas in mice responding to treatment, delayed renal toxicity was evident. The renal toxicity was not unexpected given the dosimetry estimates obtained from our biodistribution studies. In general, these studies underestimate the total dose because they average out the dose based on the weight of the entire kidney, whereas most of the activity would be expected to be concentrated in the tubules. Although renal toxicity is usually seen at late time points (month or years) after doses in the range of 20 Gy, when sensitive methods to assess renal effects are used, earlier changes may be observed (44)
. Behr et al. (45)
evaluated the effect of high radiation dose to the kidney delivered with an 90Y-Fab. In that studied they showed that animals receiving >100 Gy to the kidney showed a steep increase in BUN and acute nephritis at 1 week after treatment. Mice receiving an estimated 83 Gy to the kidneys developed renal toxicity and death as early as 5 weeks. In contrast those receiving <66 Gy had no renal toxicity (45)
. In our pretargeted study doses of 90Y-DOTA-biotin, 72 Gy did not result in renal toxicity (29)
. The toxicity that we observed in this study occurred early and at estimated doses of
8 Gy or 40 Sievert if a relative biological effectiveness of 5 is used. These values are much lower than those that resulted in renal toxicity for 90Y Fab or Fab' (45
, 46)
. In contrast to the finding of Behr et al. (46)
where the maximal tolerated dose of 213Bi-Fab' was 54 Gy we observed toxicity at a much lower level of 7.8 Gy. These differences may be related to the microdosimetric distribution of the 213Bi Fab' versus the 213Bi-DOTA-biotin and warrant additional investigation. A less likely possibility as that there was the presence of free actinium, but this is unlikely, because this has not been seen in our delayed assays.
No toxicity was seen in the liver, lung, or gastrointestinal tract based on the autopsy results and plasma chemistries. Bone marrow toxicity was not a major finding at the dose levels used. The main changes in CBC were lymphopenia, which is not surprising because lymphocytes are very radiosensitive. Histological findings of splenic lymphoid depletion and small splenic size were also noted. Some decreases in platelet count were also observed. These tended to occur early and then normalize and were not felt to be responsible for the deaths of any of the mice observed.
The nonspecific radiation delivered with HAT-SA showed a similar toxicity profile in that evidence of an elevated BUN was noted at the 37 MBq 213Bi-DOTA-biotin dose level, and pathological findings were also noted in the kidneys. At this dose, some evidence of a nonspecific tumor response was also noted. Similar nonspecific antitumor effects have also been reported by others (47) .
Other studies using a 213Bi-labeled intact antibody in the treatment of tumor masses have also demonstrated toxicity at therapeutic or subtherapeutic doses. Lung toxicity was seen by Kennel et al. (48)
when targeting lung metastasis with antibodies directed at lung vasculature. Dose-limiting toxicity has been also reported with other
emitters. The use of 212Bi-anti-Tac monoclonal antibody resulted in marrow toxicity (42)
. Studies with 225Ac showed that a dose of 1 µCi resulted in a wasting syndrome with marrow ablation, splenic atrophy, and some gastrointestinal toxicity (49
, 50)
.
In conclusion, pretargeting of tumor masses with B3-SA results in rapid and high concentration of 213Bi-DOTA-biotin in the tumor that can lead to tumor responses and in some mice can result in complete elimination of tumor xenografts. However, a significant amount of radioactivity is rapidly deposited in the kidneys, resulting in a high dose being delivered to that organ. These results with tumor nodules contrast with those observed in a murine xenograft model of human leukemia, where effective therapy of the isolated malignant cells could be achieved with pretargeting with the
emitter 213Bi with acceptable toxicity. The dose delivered to the mice in the present study involving tumor masses was such that when therapeutic levels were achieved, dose-limiting toxicity resulting in death was observed. Thus, the therapeutic ratio was unfavorable. To improve the therapeutic index, renal radiation protectants may be useful. These results dictate that to progress to clinical trials in humans with pretargeted 213Bi-DOTA-biotin, careful evaluation of the dose delivered to the kidney in vivo and a strategy of slow escalation of the dose while carefully evaluating renal function are necessary.
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Requests for reprints: J. Carrasquillo, Department of Nuclear Medicine, 10 Center Drive MSC-1180, Bethesda, MD 20892-1180. Phone: (301) 496-6455; Fax: (301) 402-4085; E-mail: jcarrasquillo{at}cc.NIH.gov
Received 9/ 5/03; revised 1/12/04; accepted 1/19/04.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-expressing adult T-cell leukemia with yttrium-90-labeled anti-Tac. Blood, 86: 4063-75, 1995.
-particle emitter labeled antibody: Bi-213-HuM195 (anti-CD33) in patients with leukemia. J Nucl Med, 40: 1935-46, 1999.
-emitting Bi-213-labeled antibody constructs for clinical use. J Nucl Med, 40: 1722-7, 1999.
-particle emitter. Nucl Med Biol, 25: 241-6, 1998.[CrossRef][Medline]
-emitting radionuclide, bismuth 213. Blood, 100: 208-16, 2002.
-emitting radiotherapeutic agents. Int J Rad Appl Instrum Part A, 38: 129-37, 1987.[CrossRef]
-particle emitters in-vivo at low-doses. Radiat Res, 137: 352-60, 1994.[CrossRef][Medline]
-expressing lymphoma utilizing the
-emitting radionuclide-conjugated monoclonal antibody 212Bi-anti-Tac. Cancer Res, 54: 4362-70, 1994.
versus low-LET ß emitters in radioimmunotherapy of solid tumors: therapeutic efficacy and dose-limiting toxicity of Bi-213- versus Y-90-labeled CO171A Fab fragments in a human colonic cancer model. Cancer Res, 59: 2635-43, 1999.
-particle emitter At-211. Radiat Res, 157: 633-41, 2002.[CrossRef][Medline]
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
M. P. Kelly, F. T. Lee, K. Tahtis, F. E. Smyth, M. W. Brechbiel, and A. M. Scott Radioimmunotherapy with {alpha}-Particle Emitting 213Bi-C-Functionalized trans-Cyclohexyl-Diethylenetriaminepentaacetic Acid-Humanized 3S193 Is Enhanced by Combination with Paclitaxel Chemotherapy Clin. Cancer Res., September 15, 2007; 13(18): 5604s - 5612s. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. M. Pagel, A. Pantelias, N. Hedin, S. Wilbur, L. Saganic, Y. Lin, D. Axworthy, D. K. Hamlin, D. S. Wilbur, A. K. Gopal, et al. Evaluation of CD20, CD22, and HLA-DR Targeting for Radioimmunotherapy of B-Cell Lymphomas Cancer Res., June 15, 2007; 67(12): 5921 - 5928. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. M. Reilly Radioimmunotherapy of Solid Tumors: The Promise of Pretargeting Strategies Using Bispecific Antibodies and Radiolabeled Haptens J. Nucl. Med., February 1, 2006; 47(2): 196 - 199. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
G. J. Forster, E. B. Santos, P. M. Smith-Jones, P. Zanzonico, and S. M. Larson Pretargeted Radioimmunotherapy with a Single-Chain Antibody/Streptavidin Construct and Radiolabeled DOTA-Biotin: Strategies for Reduction of the Renal Dose J. Nucl. Med., January 1, 2006; 47(1): 140 - 149. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
H. Karacay, P.-Y. Brard, R. M. Sharkey, C.-H. Chang, E. A. Rossi, W. J. McBride, D. R. Ragland, I. D. Horak, and D. M. Goldenberg Therapeutic Advantage of Pretargeted Radioimmunotherapy Using a Recombinant Bispecific Antibody in a Human Colon Cancer Xenograft Clin. Cancer Res., November 1, 2005; 11(21): 7879 - 7885. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||